Niall Ferguson - Rubin Report [May 2018]

6E7F7059-2B59-4809-B6B6-0439CBC8B5D7.png

Niall Ferguson + Dave Rubin

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VKkNIOkGtnQ

  • History departments have moved to the “monochrome left" , in his estimation

  • Definition of defeat in the culture war is that it’s imperceptible 

    • Often it’s a replacement problem

    • Conservative historians weren’t ever replaced

    • The left was good at succession; that was the important game

  • Stanford history department wanted no part of him; only Hoover affiliation

    • Unlike at Harvard; was a pariah at Stanford

    • Implicit rule that you don’t hire right-leaning historians or grad students

  • Students in a class he lectured in hadn’t considered the religious angle of 9/11

    • Howard Zinn’s books are most prominent; but just one perspective

  • IDW…such mystique and interest

    • How could he be part of it, when he’s been in establishments for so long 

    • Seemed disingenuous to put himself in same category as Brett Weinstein and others

    • But it’s not about denial of platform: about whether you’re seen to speak for those who feel that they’ve been silenced

  • Cowardice is the most powerful force in human history

    • Seen it with his wife, and those who hesitate to support her

    • Fear of getting targeted by jihad, or something

  • Biggest newspapers have cultures like colleges

    • NYT, FT..

  • The guilty until proven innocent model of current outrage..

    • It’s like a wheel of fate, medieval style 

  • Scots have a self-image of courage and boldness

    • Marching towards gunfire, bagpipes playing

  • When to NYU imminently after 9/11

    • Feels like it comes from his Scottish feeling of defiance 

  • Soviets recruited British sympathizers in academia 

    • Single most successful act of Russian espionage 

    • Very exclusive network infiltration 

  • Took the Remain position, due to friendship with Cameron, Osborne and others

  • Found arguments of Brexit advocates as unconvincing 

    • That you’ll recoup money and give it to domestic services

    • Immigration was the issue

    • Britain was subject to open borders, and inheriting Germany’s (or others) immigration policies 

    • Feels he was wrong initially; can admit that

    • Should’ve advised Cameron that he advocated for Brexit after there was pitiful progress on immigration across EU 

  • Not a fan of Theresa May 

  • In this weird scenario where Brexit is being implemented by those who really don’t want it

    • Disaster to be subject to rules of EU, through trade or whatever, without getting the top-tier upside

  • Thinks this whole fiasco can lead the way to Corbyn and totally leftist government